Cat in the Rain (2)
Ernest Hemingway’s “Cat in the Rain” is a short
story which describes misunderstanding and indifference in a relationship
between a man and a woman.
At first glance, this is a simple story about a
couple who travels together to Italy and enjoy spending time together. In fact,
the author gives some prompts which prove how these people are unhappy
together.
To begin with, the mood of the story itself is
sad. The author often repeats that it is raining: “It was raining. The rain
dripped from the palm trees. The sea line broke in a long line in the rain…” It creates the atmosphere of sadness and
unhappiness.
Almost the whole action takes place in the
room. Probably the author in such a way wants to emphasize that this couple is
not interested in anything. Although they are travelling it seems that most of
the time they spend in the room, each doing his/her business. The most
indifferent to that what happens around is the husband. When the author writes
about the husband he mentions his position in the room: “her husband offered
from the bed”, “lying propped up with the two pillows at the foot of the bed”. George
feels comfortable in his world, in the bed with a book, whereas his wife is
ready to go under a heavy rain to get the cat. They are too different.
Moreover, the author shows the wife’s interest towards another character of the
story, the hotel-keeper: “The wife liked him. She liked the deadly serious way
he received any complaints. She liked his dignity. She liked the way he felt
about being a hotel-keeper. She liked his old, heavy face and big hands.” So
many “she liked”, but focused on absolutely strange man. Not a single “she
liked” for her husband. It proves the wife was not happy with her husband.
The author does not describe the characters
directly. So the reader can characterize them from the point of view of their
behavior and dialogues.
As to the title, “cat” is a symbol. On the one
hand it is a symbol of wife’s loneliness. The cat was sitting alone in the
rain, lonely and helpless, like the wife probably felt in her marriage. On the
other hand it symbolizes wife’s desires. She repeats: “I wanted it so much. I
wanted that poor kitty”. And then she says: “And I want to eat at a table with
my own silver and I want candles. And I want it to be spring and I want to
brush my hair out in front of a mirror and I want a kitty and I want some new
clothes.” I think the cat and all these things she wants are connected. Well, a
cat is often associated with home and cosiness. And probably the wife missed it
in her relationship with husband. That’s why the author repeats that the wife
wants that cat so much.
So, in order to understand this short story the
reader has to read between the lines. Only in this way the reader is able to
understand that in fact this story is about lonely people, for who is difficult
to find a person which would be similar to them.
Dear Ania,
ОтветитьУдалитьAt the beginning, I would like to say that you have done a nice job anyway! However, I suppose that your analysis is too short. The paragraphs are also very short. You have missed some issues which are important in an analysis. For example, the summary of the story, maybe something about the exposition, the rising action, the climax, the falling action, the denoument, the more detailed description of the characters. You could have developed some ideas, for example in the paragraph nr. 3 about the mood. Some other remarks are:
1) As I have said, there are some very small paragraps. For example, the paragraph 1,2,3,5,7. Actually only 2 of them are more developed.
2) You could have developed the paragraph about the characterization of the personages because you have only said that they can be characterize from their behaviour and dialogues. You could have provided this with some examples.
3) In what way is the cat connected to all those things that the woman wants?
I think this is all I can say. By the way, I like your conclusion: "in fact this story is about lonely people, for who is difficult to find a person which would be similar to them." Have a nice week dear!
Yours ever,
Alina
Aurica Cazac's comment:
ОтветитьУдалить'Too short I can say but with good ideas. However I think you should develop your paragraphs, and provide more arguments. I did not see in your analysis the summary, the analysis of the characters. The concluding sentence does not reveal the whole analysis and is not in a connection with the topic because in the first sentence you spoke about" misunderstanding and indifference" and in the last paragraph about " this story is about lonely people,". Good luck.'
Good ideas, indeed. However, I totally agree with the girls!
ОтветитьУдалить